Facilitate Product × Engineering collaboration
Client
SAP
Service
Product Design
Industry
Financials
Year
2020
This is the strategy note behind the tax credits case: how design and engineering matched each of the three apps to the Fiori technology that would ship it fastest, without losing features. Result: two of the three apps shipped on Fiori Elements, reaching customers sooner with almost no loss of features.
About the Project
Applications that use the SAP Fiori design system can be developed using two technologies: SAPUI5 or Fiori Elements.
SAPUI5 is a front-end framework based on open technologies like HTML5, JavaScript and CSS.
Fiori Elements is a scaffolding framework based on backend annotations.
Which technology should each app use?
To define which technology apps from the “Taxes management suite” should be developed, considering team expertise and design limitations from each approach.
Pros and cons
SAPUI5
Pros: more flexibility on design.
Cons: team didn’t have too much expertise with the technology.
Cons: it would take more time to deliver.
Fiori Elements
Pros: styles and controls updated by the central team; team had more expertise with backend development.
Cons: pre-defined set of designs.
SAPUI5 for flexibility, Fiori Elements for speed
Considering the above limitations, I worked with the team to specify the technology of development:
SAPUI5: Configure filters to specify integration criteria;
Fiori Elements: Create Credit Control from imported documents;
Fiori Elements: Post tax data to Financials.
Also, the order of development, which was:
Applications 2 and 3:
They were developed with Fiori Elements to deliver value faster to customers, while they were reports-based apps, there was almost no loss of features.
Application 1:
The suite was delivered in the first version with a preset of configurations to give the customers a faster adoption.
If I did it again, I'd weigh the v1 preset configurations against flexibility sooner — Fiori Elements shipped value faster, but the presets limited what the config app could do.



